Unfortunately, I have not held an interview yet so my post will be a little strange. I did schedule a meeting with an English teacher for the end of this week so I will edit/update this post (or make a new post) to explain the process and address these questions better.
I have, however, started sending out emails with my survey attached to random High School English teachers across the U.S. So far, I have received three responses (two from Alaska and one from Florida).
Here are the results from my survey:
How do you encourage students to take risks in your classroom?
-I used to require a 15-min journal entry a day, I also require students to write about half a page before any class discussion (as it greatly enhances the quality of discussion)
-I run writing workshops with 3-5 selected papers that are nameless (names are removed) the students all take the papers home, read them and write feedback to the writers. Then we sit in a circle and read each paper and discuss how to improve them. Also we write 3 days a week, after testing we get to poetry which encourages more risk taking. Students are required to submit a piece of writing for publication or to a writing contest once per semester.
-Students write every day with different parameters, once a week they write in creative writing notebooks, three times a week they respond to prompts with opinions or analysis of a passage.
Have you ever put limitations on student's writing? (If yes, what?)
- If students need to swear to be authentic or realistic to the situation in which they are writing about, they can swear. Depending on the assignment, I remind students to be aware of the audience and look at tone, word choice and style accordingly. Also word limits, either over 500 words, or under 500 words.
-With research papers yes, I will blacklist certain topics that really can no longer provide solid balanced, researched arguments (ex. gun control, abortion - media sensitive topics). Much less limitation with creative writing. Remind students of what audience they are writing for. I encourage students to write about "hard things" those topics that people are afraid to write about. I get some very good writing from those topics, but it does take courage sometimes.
-I won't accept racism, sexism, or homophobia in student writing or speaking. Certainly we can talk about these issues, but not in ways that insult or disparage others.
Has a parent/administrator had a problem with student work? If yes, what happened?
-A student wrote about a teacher that had been fired and jailed for inappropriate behavior with students and how it impacted her. She wanted to submit the essay to a writing contest so the principal read it and asked her to make it more anonymous and the paper was given to the legal department of the district.
These answers were great and exactly what I wanted to know about. I found the last story very important and I am glad that the student wasn't held back but rather legally bound to remove all names. It would have been easy for the teacher and principal to say "no, this is not appropriate", but they all stood behind the student!
Jess, I LOVE that you thought to send surveys out across the US to various teachers. How did you find their e-mails? It's great that you have an interview schedule but I think these are great primary sources and you received some really good feedback from the few that responded. I agree with you about that last story. I definitely would have had an issue if they did not allow her to submit it. I can understand that, for legal purposes, she would need to change names or something. Seems like you're on a good trajectory here. I'm very interested to see if you get anymore survey responses.
ReplyDeleteI will be stealing your idea of sending out emails to folks around US! This is actually making me think that some published teacher researches might be fairly approachable.....
ReplyDeleteI also have very specific ideas of what censorship means, and I like reading your blog because it's broadening my idea of it. The last instance was certainly not something I had thought of. I liked that the school supported her, and the fact that she felt comfortable writing the piece in the first place is evidence to me of a positive school culture. And now I am thinking about how school culture impacts censorship....hmmmm
These responses are so exciting! It is great to see that teachers encourage their kids to dig deep, but with the exception that disparaging others will not be accepted. I think these are the sorts of teachers that are sending sensitive, thoughtful, and creative people out into the world.
ReplyDelete(Also, I don't know if you've ever heard/read it but there's a great book called Places I Never Meant to Be and it's a collection of short stories written by authors that have been censored in the classroom, like Judy Blume, and the stories are wonderful and also are stories that students could produce in classroom conditions like those teachers who responded to you. Anyway, I just thought you might like to know!)
Omg your idea of sending out emails to random teachers is so cool! I'm definitely going to try one or two...
ReplyDeleteYou are going to receive so many good responses especially since now you are not just focusing on RI you are doing the wholeUS, I'm very intrigued.
Jessica!!!! I love this topic. I live the questions you are asking and the true responses the teachers are giving. It is wonderfl that you have emailed teachers from around the U.S. It can give you a much better sense of censorship as a whole.
ReplyDelete